Why no Blu-ray Music-only Format

Disc players
Why no Blu-ray Music-only Format

The forthcoming Sony BDP-S550 is certainly a breakthrough product that will provide a hardware platform that might spur the release of Blu-ray music titles from specialty labels.

I agree that the professional SACD community (record companies releasing SACD) should turn their attention to Blu-ray. Blu-ray holds more long-term promise, and has the potential for mass-market acceptance.

I think we'll see more artists follow Neil Young's lead in releasing their back catalogs in Blu-ray. The format and technology infrastructure are there to deliver high-res music titles on Blu-ray. In addition to offering better sound quality, Blu-ray has the advantage (from the artist's viewpoint) of not being easily transmitted through file-sharing.

The music industry doesn't believe that the mass market will care about a higher-quality audio carrier. They don't want to sink a lot of money into establishing a new format (and all that it entails, from manufacturing to marketing to retailing) that they think will occupy only a niche at best, and would perhaps be irrelevant in the age of downloads.