After establishing rather quickly and that the BDA-3 could deliver such a high level of musical engagement, I moved on to assess the two primary new features: its HDMI inputs and DSD decoding. I encountered only one operational glitch with the BDA-3’s HDMI inputs: losing the HDMI signal lock—e.g. if the source is powered off—generates an audible pop. In all fairness, this issue is hardly unique to the BDA-3, and perhaps can be addressed by a future firmware update. [Bryston says, “Pops have been reduced or eliminated in most circumstances as of latest firmware released Nov, 2016.” —Ed.]
With both CDs and DVDs, the HDMI outputs of both my Sony BDP-BX37 and BDP-S6200 Blu-ray players sounded decisively more refined and neutral than those players’ SPDIF outputs, mirroring exactly what I have heard from three generations of Oppo Blu-ray players over the past several years. SPDIF from the Sony players sounded veiled, flattened, compressed, and jumbled, while the HDMI connection allowed music to flow with a smoother and more lucid clarity.
I pressed into service my aging Marantz DV-9600 universal DVD/SACD player, a considerably more robust product than the flyweight Sony Blu-ray players. First impressions of the SPDIF output of the Marantz reminded me of why that unit has proven its mettle both as a player and a transport over the years, delivering a lively, direct immediacy. HDMI from the Sony BDP-BX37 initially sounded comparatively muted, but after iterative comparisons it became clear that the Marantz player’s energetic character was due to a host of “old school” digital artifacts: ringing, diffuse temporal smearing, “peak shriek,” etc. In contrast, HDMI from the Sony player sounded considerably more relaxed and linear, both dynamically and across the audio frequency spectrum, better preserving the purity of instrumental timbres and the complex interplay of musical lines.
The ability of the Bryston BDA-3 to achieve such a high level of sonic performance from the HDMI output of an inexpensive universal disc player is a most welcome development, considering the finite lifespan of any optical-disc player, regardless of price. Over the decades, I have been privileged to hear some of the finest CD transports ever designed, most memorably the Goldmund Mimesis 36 ($14,990), but eventually all such products will need to be repaired, and essential core components may simply no longer be available. Bearing this cold truth in mind, the BDA-3 will be of particular interest to readers who continue to prefer the simplicity of optical-disc playback to the daunting task of migrating their music library to a file-based playback paradigm.
Moving on to DSD sources further solidified my enthusiasm for the BDA-3. All of the aforementioned virtues were maintained during DSD playback, with additional gains in solidity, dimensionality, tonal richness, precision of note shape, and dynamic expressiveness. The aforementioned Marantz DV-9600 faithfully served as my benchmark SACD player for many years, but in this case only exemplified how much “that was then, but this is now.” Regardless of genre or musical complexity, the vintage Marantz SACD player sounded comparatively grungy, edgy, sluggish, turgid, and confused.
In head-shakingly stark contrast, SACD playback over HDMI from the Sony BDP-BX37 (used exclusively after the BDP-6200’s disc drawer mysteriously locked shut) sounded dramatically more open, incisive, controlled, focused, linear, and responsive to the ebb and flow of musical contours. All manner of details were far easier to discern through the Bryston DAC, such as the exquisite textural precision of Mahler’s scoring, the differentiation of individual instruments within massed string passages, and the sheer ease of following Bernstein’s expressive direction of the New York Philharmonic performing the Titan Symphony (Sony SACD). Indeed, hearing the BDA-3 play this SACD via HDMI from an inexpensive Sony Blu-ray player evoked fond recollection of the reference-grade Marantz SA-1 SACD player responsible for my personal “conversion” into an enthusiastic supporter of the nascent SACD format at the beginning of the millennium.
Listeners sometimes draw inappropriate conclusions from misleading “apples vs. oranges” product comparisons. For instance, comparing a really good (and usually expensive) CD player against a mediocre (and usually relatively inexpensive) SACD player might lead to the erroneous conclusion that DSD offers little benefit over CD’s 16-bit/44.1kHz PCM resolution. In order to test this hypothesis, I ripped the CD layer of several SACDs, and selected a group of tracks from only those albums that preserved the same waveform envelope shape as the equivalent tracks on the SACD layer. I played these 16/44.1 PCM files from the Bryston BDP-1, and compared them to the DSD layer of the SACDs, connected via HDMI from the Sony Blu-ray player.
This intentionally asymmetric comparison would thus pit a purportedly superior source format (file playback) against a purportedly superior data format (DSD). Which factor would dominate? Well, this comparison was also surprisingly clear and definitive: SACDs played via HDMI exhibited the smooth fluidity, expressive nuance, dynamic resolution, grounded solidity, and easy, natural flow that make DSD so compelling. The CD-resolution files sounded comparatively crude and rough-edged, with clunky dynamic shifts, vague timing, and smeared spatial focus. Despite the advantages of file-based playback, the CD resolution files couldn’t hold a proverbial candle to DSD’s obvious strengths.
Not surprisingly, DSD file playback from the Bryston BDP-1 Digital Player (using the Oyaide Type A USB cable) surpassed SACD playback via HDMI. This performance differential was consistent with what I have heard from playback of PCM files vs. their optical-disc equivalents over the past decade. There’s really no point in deconstructing or dissecting the elevated performance of DSD file playback over SACD playback. Everything described above about SACD playback was simply better with DSD file playback from the BDP-1.Progress in digital playback essentially comes down to reducing the artifacts that distract the listener from following the music. The evolutionary development of Bryston’s DACs from the original BDA-1 to the BDA-3 has been an object lesson in digital progress. Bryston’s BDA-3 DAC surpasses the high-value performance standard set by the BDA-2, enables inexpensive HDMI-equipped disc players to function as premium source components, and adds exceptionally engaging DSD playback to its potent mix of virtues. I’ve already purchased the review sample as my new reference.
Specs & Pricing
PCM sample rates: 44.1, 48, 88.2, 96, 176.4, 192 kHz, 352.8, 384kHz
DSD sampled rates: DSD, DSD128, DSD256
Output level: 4.0 volts balanced, 2.0 volts unbalanced
THD + Noise: 0.002%
Dimensions: 17" x 3.63" x 11.12"
Weight: 8.5 lbs.
Shipping weight: 15 lbs.
677 Neal Drive
K9J 6X7 Canada
Goldmund Studio turntable, Breuer Type 8 tonearm, Audio Technica OC9ML phono cartridge, Sony BDP-BX37 Blu-ray/SACD player, Sony BDP-S6200 Blu-ray/SACD player, Monoprice #10251 HDMI audio converter, ESI Juli@ PCI sound card, FiiO X3 2nd Gen portable music player, Tascam DA-3000 mastering recorder, Bryston BDP-1 digital player, Bryston BDP-2 digital player, Bryston BDA-2 digital-to-analog converter, Bryston BP26-MC preamplifier and MPS2 power supply, Bryston 9B-SST power amplifier (4 channels), custom bi-amplified Manger MSW loudspeaker system with passive line-level high-pass crossover and active NHT X2 low-pass electronic crossover, Empirical Design cables and power cords, Oyaide Class A USB cable, customized Brickwall surge filters, two dedicated 20 amp AC circuits, ASC TubeTraps